Retro Round-up for December 19


posted 12/19/2008 by Cyril Lachel
other articles by Cyril Lachel
One Page Platforms: Multiple
Every week Cyril Lachel comes down from his giant castle in the hills to provide the final word on all of the classic downloadable games and retro compilations. This is the Retro Round-Up, your official guide to the best (and worst) in classic gaming for the Nintendo Virtual Console, Xbox Live Arcade and PlayStation Network. Join us as we shed some light on what games are worth your five or ten dollars, and what games you should avoid at all costs. For more information about these games (and retro gaming in general) we invite you to check out Defunct Games.

It's been a month since we last brought you an episode of the Retro Round-Up. We've been vexed by Thanksgiving and then Cyril coming down with a bad case of the flu. In that time we've had plenty of retro releases piling up, including releases for the Virtual Console, Xbox Live Arcade, PlayStation Network and GameTap. So this week we've decided to take a look back and recap all of the retro games released since our last episode of the Retro Round-Up. So get ready for a larger-than-normal episode of everybody's favorite retro show, the Retro Round-Up!

Boogerman: A Pick and Flick Adventure (Genesis)
What Is It?
This is the week of Thanksgiving, so what better time to unleash a game called Boogerman: A Pick and Flick Adventure? Okay, the day you sit down and overeat with your family is probably not the best time to play a game where the hero picks his nose and uses it as a weapon. Then again, is there ever a time where talking about Boogerman is appropriate? I think not. In a lot of ways Boogerman represents the American gaming scene in the 1990s. This was a decade where people were demanding bigger and grosser games. We weren't satisfied with the Japanese fighting games like Street Fighter or Final Fight; instead we needed our virtual pugilists to shower their opponents with blood and guts. The same was true with the 2D platforming scene; we didn't want another boring old Sonic or Mario game, we wanted people to fart, burp and pick their nose. We wanted to make sure that every mother or father that went to their local game store knew that video games were meant for 10 year old boys, not sophisticated young adults. The good news is that Boogerman is a surprisingly good looking game, with fluid animation and some interesting levels. However, it's impossible for me to look at this game without thinking that maybe it's not the best ambassador for video game culture. Obviously they are going for gross here, but to me it just feels more inauthentic and, worse yet, extremely immature. If you're a ten year old boy then you'll probably like it, everybody else should just ignore this week's Virtual Console release.

Does It Still Hold Up?
Although limited, the gameplay is as solid as you would want from a game called Boogerman. Our hero has a few moves that are easy to pull off, but most of the game he'll just be jumping on bad guys, dodging projectile attacks and making his way from left to right. Perhaps the best part of this package is the graphics, which even now look really strong. If you can make it past how ludicrous the idea is then you'll find a game with good production values, but you really have to be in the right kind of mindset to enjoy a game called Boogerman.

Is It Worth The Money?
I can understand people having nostalgia for this game, it's not like there were a lot of games out there that revolved around the hero farting on enemies. In some ways this is like a Howard Stern skit brought to life ... or, at least brought to video game life. Either way, Boogerman is a solid 2D platformer wrapped in one of the most unappealing packages you will ever see. I can't imagine anybody who loved the game 13 years ago would find this anything but reprehensible now. But maybe I'm wrong; perhaps there is still a market out there for Boogerman. I don't personally enjoy it, but if you're a 10 year old boy who loves fart jokes, then this game is mades specifically for you.


Enduro Racer (Master System)
What Is It?
When the Sega Master System was launched in the mid-1980s one of the debut titles was Hang-On, the exciting port of one of the best arcade racers (of the time). Fans embraced the game's fast-paced action and solid controls; it was a perfect example of the type of experience we wanted from our 3D racing games. Enduro Racer ignores everything we learned in Hang-On and creates a racing game that is mildly entertaining, but not as good as what has come before it. Enduro Racer is a lot like a cross between Hang-On and the NES classic, Excitebike. Instead of being 3D (or even 2D), the game uses a strange isometric angle that can be a little confusing, but ultimately manageable. Despite the different camera angle, you control Enduro Racer exactly as you would Hang-On or any other faux-3D game of that era. You can't really move in or out of the screen, but you can dodge things left and right, which is something ... I guess. The good news is that Enduro Racer is not the worst game on the Sega Master System, but that doesn't mean you should spend even a dollar on this turd!

Does It Still Hold Up?
Don't be confused by the game's weird angle, when it comes right down to it this is basically just a rip-off of Excitebike. The problem is, this game is nowhere near as exciting as Excitebike. The controls are sluggish, the obstacles are hard to dodge and the camera angle makes everything as painful as possible. I'm sure there are people out there that can find some fun in this Master System racer, but I would say that it definitely does not hold up.

Is It Worth The Money?
This is one of those Sega Master System games I bought at a used game store for around a buck, and even then I felt a little ripped off. At five dollars it's hard to justify buying this game, especially with so many other (better) racing games on the Virtual Console. This was an interesting experiment on the Master System, but twenty years later there's no need to further that experiment.


Metal Slug 2
(Neo Geo)
What Is It?

Metal Slug 2 is more than the sequel to SNK's top ranked Contra-like series. It's more than just another game where you go around shooting every bad guy that gets in the way. It's the game that actually elevates the franchise to a whole new level, giving us cool new weapons, vehicles and some of the most memorable levels of all of the Metal Slug games. And best of all, it's just in time for SNK Playmore's release of Metal Slug 7 on the Nintendo DS. This 2D shooter is a bit antiquated by today's standards, but that shouldn't keep you from having a great time running through the levels either with a friend or by yourself. What sets this series apart from all of the other 2D shooters is its attention to small details, especially when it comes to character animations. The game is funny, which is not something you can say about more games in the genre. It's not without a few problems, but Metal Slug 2 is definitely a lot of fun.

Does It Still Hold Up?
I know I bring this up every time I review a Metal Slug game, but why the heck can't I shoot diagonally? This is one of those things that should have been rectified in the second game, yet a half dozen games later and we're still dealing with this problem. Outside of that, the game exists entirely because of the amazing animation and crazy enemies you have to kill. It feels a bit dated, but there's no doubt that the bulk of Metal Slug 2 still holds up well.

Is It Worth The Money?
While I'm giving this game a caution, the truth is that you probably shouldn't buy Metal Slug 2. It's not that it's a bad game, because it's not. It's not that you shouldn't experience this game at least once in your life. It's that you could buy the entire Metal Slug Anthology on the Nintendo Wii for a mere $30. Heck, at this point you can probably find it for under $20! That's seven different games for a few dollars more. If you wanted to buy all of the Neo Geo Metal Slug games you would be paying close to $60, but for $20 - $30 you can get a near complete collection and never have to worry about how much hard drive space you have left. That's definitely the way to go. If you simply must buy these games on the Virtual Console so be it, but I would personally wait until they upload Metal Slug 3.

Metal Slug
Page 1 of 2