To say that I loved Puzzle Quest: Challenger of the Warlords would be a gross understatement. When I first got the preview build of the PSP game I instantly fell in love, shouting my admiration from the rooftops. Over the course of 2007 I must have put hundreds of hours into that game, which was a large contributing factor to why I named it my game of 2007. I have an emotional connection to the game as well; when I suffered second degree burns on my right hand, Puzzle Quest DS was the only game I could play. Between the two portable versions and the Xbox Live Arcade expansion pack, I put more time into this little puzzler than just about any other game.
So given my love and excitement for the game, you might think that I would automatically love D3's brand new spin-off, Puzzle Quest Galactrix. After all, it takes everything that was good about the original Puzzle Quest and trades in the fantasy for the sci-fi (or, if you know you're classic RPGs, it trades "Fantasy" for "Phantasy"). But alas, there's just something about this 2009 model that isn't the same. It looks and feels like Puzzle Quest, but there are enough changes to keep it from living up to my (albeit lofty) expectations.
As you can tell from the name, Puzzle Quest Galactrix takes place in space. You play one of several young pilots who just graduated from the Space Academy and is looking to earn some money around the solar system. The story is generic sci-fi through and through, and like the original game, it's easy to avoid. I'm sure there are people that will find something to like about the endless conversations these unlikable characters have, but for me the stories have always been inconsequential to the fun of the game.
This time around you are free to move around the entire galaxy. You use a gigantic map full of various systems, from Talus to Gemini to Alpha Centauri all the way down to Gehenna. Each of these systems has a series of planets, moons and space stations to visit. You can mine for minerals on the various moons, search for missions on the planets and take on any number of warships. In a lot of ways this map is no different from what we saw in the original Puzzle Quest, but there's definitely something cool about tooling around such an expansive solar system.
Much like the first game, the one on one combat is the real draw. And while the basic idea remains the same (match puzzle pieces to inflict enough damage to take out your opponent), the actual combat is a bit different. In the original Puzzle Quest you match pieces on a Bejeweled-style game board. However, in this game you are playing in a Hexic-style board, that is to say instead of only having four directions to match, you now have to deal with six. At first this seems like an interesting twist on the original gameplay, but before long I started to have major issues with this approach.
The biggest problem is that it takes a simple concept and makes it too complicated. In the first game you always knew which way the tiles were going to fall (from the top), however in this game you really have to pay attention to the direction of the incoming tiles. You manipulate the tile direction based on how you move. For example, if you move the tile left, the new tiles will come from the left. On paper that sounds simple enough, but I found that I would often forget this rule and have trouble planning ahead. I suppose with practice I will get better at adhering to that rule, though this added complication didn't add anything to the gameplay.
The brand new board also means that more of the game is dependent on luck. Now I won't lie to you, there were times when I felt like the computer was cheating. But this takes that complaint to a whole new, um, solar system. No matter how strong my little spaceship got, I always felt like the computer had an unfair advantage. That's certainly not the attitude I wanted to take into each battle, but I couldn't help but feel that way after only a few missions.
Much like the original Puzzle Quest, each one of the tiles is vitally important to the match. Obviously there are the attack tiles, which are denoted by number tiles. The object is to match three (or more) of these numbered tiles up to do damage. Whatever the three (or more) numbers add up to is the amount of damage you will take off. The trick this time around is that most enemy ships will have a certain level of force fields that will need to be taken down. Once you take down the force field you are free to start damaging the ship, until one of your ships is destroyed.
But don't worry too much about losing your shields, because Puzzle Quest Galactrix allows you to repair your force fields by matching blue tiles. Other tiles are for your special attacks, which will be immediately recognizable to anybody who played the first game. You can also earn experience, which means that even if you lose the battle you will still get something out of it. Even though I'm disappointed by the new game board, I am a big fan of the shield system and feel that there are some improvements to the tile system that should be brought up to over, better Puzzle Quest games.
Puzzle Quest Galactrix does make an attempt to spice things up with some variety. While you will still need to take down enemy spaceships in a one-on-one duel to the death, the game offers a lot of other mini-games to keep you entertained. The most common mini-game comes when you attempt to open up the various "Leap Gates" linking the various galaxies. To hack these gates you are given a standard board and a bunch of colors you need to match in order. For example, you might be asked to match green, silver and then blue. While you might be able to match silver and blue, you will first need to match green in order to move over to the other two colors.
Another mini-game has you mining moons for a variety of different valuables (minerals, gold, isotopes, etc.) that can be traded, sold and used in completing your missions. These mini-games feel like a throwback to the first Puzzle Quest, where you go in and match whatever valuables you want until you run out of choices. These various mini-games are fun diversions, but they aren't as much fun as battling other spaceships.
On top of an absolutely gigantic single player story, you can also go head to head with your friends. Of course, much like the first game, you really need to find somebody that you are equal to in order to have a fun time. It's a shame that the game doesn't allow for more even battles, but that's just not the way Puzzle Quest has been. Hopefully when they get around to developing the next game they'll address this concern.
The graphics and sound are about what you would expect from a Puzzle Quest game, which is to say that you will get a lot of drawn images standing and talking while cheesy music plays in the background. You don't play this game for the visuals, but rather the exciting space battles ... as told through a puzzle. I'm fine with the graphics as they are. In fact, I would probably be a little upset if the game had slick cut scenes and music from today's hottest bands. There's something about the simplistic look and sound that fits this game, even if it won't win any awards for its beauty.
On the surface it looks like Puzzle Quest Galactrix is everything I would want from an Xbox Live Arcade game. I loved the first game, I love space battles and I love all of the new technology and weapons you get to play with over the course of the game. The problem is, I don't particularly like the game. I know I should (and I wish I did), but there's something about the game this time around that doesn't feel as fresh and exciting. I have a hunch that most of my problem stems from the new game board. Had this been the traditional square board I wouldn't be so down on this release, but as it is I had a hard time getting into it. There's a lot to like in Puzzle Quest Galactrix, just don't expect this to be as fresh and fun as the original.
Puzzle Quest Galactrix sounds like a dream come true. I love the epic space battles, cool technology and, most importantly, the first game. So why is it that I can't get into this pseudo-sequel? This is a good second attempt, but I liked the first game better!